- Mark Topic as New
- Mark Topic as Read
- Float this Topic to the Top
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Printer Friendly Page
04-04-2009 04:39 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
I agree with you, if there is just a simple way to download the PDF quickly using one-click then great. I can't see why you would only want 1 page of a bill to be honest. If the bill is there, you want it all.
I have only been with Vodafone 2 years so I have only ever been online.
Not 100% sure about the emailing the bills though because of email security, and I doubt VF would do it unfortunately
Tom
04-04-2009 04:40 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
Hi Bob
This is very interesting. Which web browser do you use? Have you tried any other?
Just curious because of the way that the software reacts on different browsers.
There have been quite a few threads on here concerning the DocumentDirect software and problems which have arisen. I will see if there are any that are relevant.
Best Regards
Tom
Well I realise you're trying to help Tom, and thanks very much for that, but my browser should be irrelevant. We're looking for a solution here not a workaround. The solution is for the Vodafone billing page to a) conform to W3C standards - it doesn't!) and b) to have ONE button that enables a FULL invoice in .pdf form to be downloaded. I repeat ... just like it used to have up until November/December last year!
To answer your question though, I use Firefox 3.0.5 currently but 3.0.8 is already loaded and awaiting my restart of Firefox which I intend doing later today. I strongly suspect that in common with most corporate developers Vodafone develops to a proprietary platform (viz Microsoft) that does not conform to formal standards (even IE 8.0 fails in this regard) and according to some stats I reviewed just yesterday it is also the minority platform overall now - 43% vs the rest of the top six of which ARE all standards-compliant. Why should I (or anyone else) be expected to use an inferior, non-standards-based, less secure browser in order to satisfy Vodafone's inability to both write and test against the formal W3C standards. As a proof point of this, the very page upon which I am entering this data has 75 compliance errors and 59 warnings! And yet somehow my browser is suspected of being the problem! Duh!
I've managed to get to the point where the DocumentDirect software comes up and offers me a "GOTO page xx of 6" option (no use as I want ALL six pages in ONE .pdf) and a field that says CTN (whatever CTN represents - jargon should be avoided especially when there is a WHOLE empty screen into which a PROPER description can be placed) - MAYBE this is where I can get something I want but until I know what CTN means I'm stumped.
Oh and why does the "goto" box shrink my browser to a tiny window every time? Don't bother to answer that, I already know. It's because Vodafone (apparently) develop to proprietary standards rather than the formal W3C ones which would ensure it worked CORRECTLY on Firefox, Opera, Mozilla, Safari, Chrome, et al.. (have I beaten the standards thing to death yet or not?)
Proprietary SUCKS - Standards CONFORMANCE (not compatiblity) rules.
Best regards, Bob.
04-04-2009 04:43 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
... If we can sign up to have PDF bills emailed to us as well as access to online billing, I'll be even happier.
Excellent idea! I would sign up for that too.
04-04-2009 05:04 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
I was just trying to get some idea of what you were using etc. basically.
From what I have read, I don't think it is a browser issue (although as you say it is not W3C standard (374 errors on the home page alone!!)), I think it is something to do with your account, which obviously only the mods can help you with.
I tried what you said (about the go to page option) and that worked for me without a problem. I used Firefox 3.0.8 which obviously makes me think it is account-specific.
Best to wait and see what the mods say, because obviously at the end of the day they are the ones in the best position to get this sorted for you.
Hope it is sorted soon
Tom
04-04-2009 05:22 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
05-04-2009 02:07 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
eeePC - using native browser (Mozilla/Webkit) works! Arrrgh! What is going on?
Siemens Laptop/Debian Linux (Firefox under guise of IceWeasel) - works!
Windows 2000/Firefox 2.x now 3.0.8 (used as a storage workstation/server with SCSI disks) - works!
Windows XP/Firefox 3.0.5 (now 3.0.8) - NOT working! ######!
I still say DocumentDirect sucks big time. It's adding a whole new complication layer that adds precisely ZERO value.
Vodafone: PLEASE consider junking it for something more sane & simple.
You know KISS - Keep It Sweet & Simple
(Rather than Keep It Simple Stupid - never did like that form)
Best regards, Bob Lewis.
05-04-2009 02:22 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
Be interesting to see your findings RE download manager. Just out of interest, do you use different security software on the different computers (especially the Windows ones)? Or anything else than security software?
I agree DocumentDirect isn't great. As I said in my other posts, I have created website pages which generates PDFs in seconds, no problem at all.
Let us know how you get on anyway.
Best Regards
Tom
06-04-2009 02:10 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
I just couldn't face another day of messing about with this yesterday so I left it until today to sort out. As promised a final update on what I've done:
Having closed down Firefox and restarted (now on 3.0.8 vs 3.0.5 previously) and disabled the download manager plug-in, reset my pdf plug-in to display automatically rather than ask me via a pop-up and restarted Firefox again. I do actually get the process flow (more or less) the way it should be.
My external download manager still picks up on it, and steps in, as it is set to download stuff in batch overnight normally to avoid my 40GB monthly daytime bandwidth cap. Consequently there are a few extra steps for me to take mainly because of not using the Adobe plug-in (Adobe is such a massive resource hog consuming large amounts of memory and cpu to do nothing better or differently to Foxit). Compared to getting a .pdf from OTHER sites however it is STILL way too clunky and cumbersome (as has already been said many times).
Have since reinstated the Download Manager Plug-in -still OK
Have reinstated the pop-up check on my .pdf plug-in (basically checks to see if I want to just read or download a .pdf) - OK
Have put everything back the way I had it originally and still OK
So what was wrong?
At least I can now get to a full invoice .pdf albeit by jumping through a bunch of unnecessary and irrelevant hoops. Thank goodness I can leave it until once a quarter or every four months.
To recap then:
1. Vodafone: PLEASE scrap DocumentDirect ... PLEASE! Use a simpler, cleaner, more direct access either to the full .pdf or as previously to the "print bill" so that we can individually print to a .pdf document at our end.
2. There simply is NO need nor justification to have such a complication as in 1. JUST to be able to print particular pages of a .pdf. Duh!
Who came up with the idea? Muddled, muddled thinking - Firing Squad on the roundabout outside HQ at dawn so we can all watch eh? Adobe Acrobat Reader and the independent readers like Foxit (I use) provide this capability native for any .pdf. file. Foxit (maybe also Abobe Acrobat Reader and others) even provides a free means of annotating the bill should it be necessary and then saving the document with said annotations.
3. If NOTHING else is changed, the link that goes to the selection boxes for the download from the DocumentDirect toolbar definitely DOES need to be changed to NOT resize the window. This anachronistic behaviour in a tabbed browser environment such as Firefox is ridiculous, since all it does is to shrink my main browser window to a tiny window that is not even sized correctly to show all the (small amount of) content!
4. Why does the download file format default to zip? The button on the "Bills" page says PDF invoice (note: "invoice" NOT "page 1"!!) and shows the Adobe .pdf logo, so why default to a .zip? Bad UI practice! It should be consistent.
5. Before making major changes to the UI in future, please have the sense to run them past a good, technically savvy (as well as computer naive) users to check them out first. If you DID do that on this occasion anyway, then it would appear that you need some new blood in your review panel.
Vodafone have two of the most effective modern communication vehicles available directly to them in SMS messages and our email addresses. We are sent enough useless advertising cr*p,
6. Finally, it's not been mentioned previously, but I might as well get the whole rant out of the way. What's happening with the site? Pages are taking upwards of 20 seconds to load and frequently I get "Sorry! Page cannot be displayed. Unfortunately your request cannot be processed".
It appears to be linked to the session timeout (which is WAY too short a period and needs to double) where the session times out but the page is not cleared down for a new one that says that the session has expired (like all the banking sites I've used do - in fact they are much more sensible because they warn you that your session is about to expire!)
BTW, my general daytime bandwidth rarely drops much below 200kByte/s and is often upwards of 800kByte/s. What is taking so long? I get faster response from my own servers located in Washington State than from Vodafone (servers located where? Newbury - 16 miles from where I am? Telehouse? My ISP is a co-lo peer in Telehouse!). In the past I've also had problems often connecting well outside normal hours when response should be lightning fast (00:00 to 02:00).
Thanks again guys for all the suggestions. Shame it wasn't possible to identify the cause of the problem. I just hope it doesn't return.
Best regards, Bob.
06-04-2009 02:27 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
Glad it is sorted, and as you say it is ashame you have to go through those steps to get it to work.
Upgrading from version 3.0.5 to 3.0.8 shouldn't make any difference. I have been using the online facility on here through Firefox for months and months (pre 3.0.5) and never had a problem using the online account facility.
One thing I will say and I don't know if it is relevant to this situation, but every so often, if I forget to clear out the "Private Data" out of Firefox, I get loads of error messages on the Vodafone Help Centre especially. When this happens I have no other problem on other websites, so it makes me think there is a compatibility issue between this site and Firefox in some way (Mods - might be worth taking note).
At least you have your PDF bills back.
All the best
Tom
06-04-2009 02:56 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
One thing I will say and I don't know if it is relevant to this situation, but every so often, if I forget to clear out the "Private Data" out of Firefox, I get loads of error messages on the Vodafone Help Centre especially. When this happens I have no other problem on other websites, so it makes me think there is a compatibility issue between this site and Firefox in some way (Mods - might be worth taking note).
Hmmm. You may have a very good point there Tom. I can't remember which site it was, but a while ago I had a problem on a site that someone suggested was due to a simliar thing around "Private Data". I would imagine that it would be cleared out on an upgrade to Firefox which might explain why everything started working again after the upgrade but without any other obvious change. I'll try to bear it in mind if I have any further problems on the site. Cheers.
Best regards, Bob.
07-04-2009 11:14 AM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
Good feedback there, this is how we can find out what people think of the systems so I'll make sure that gets passed on, especially yours, webmaestro - that must have taken a while to write. Glad to hear you're up and running now, though!
One thing to remember is, as you said, there are both "tech savvy" and "computer naive" perople, and these tend to have different ideas of how something should work, the practical logical approach versus a wish to keep the same end product they had before everything went electronic. As a result, some people want a single PDF and some want separate pages because that''s what they know. The long-term answer is obviously to find a way to allow for both without impacting performance.
I am aware that we have experienced a period of downtime recently which might bexplain the difficulties you've had accessing the website recently. The system is now running without issues again, so if you check now you should fiund the pages load without further delay.
DaveN
eForum Team
28-04-2009 10:10 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
- Firefox 3.0.8 on WinXP (SP2) (machine #1)
- Firefox 3.0.8 on Win2k (machine #2)
- Firefox 3.0.8 on Debian Linux (Machine #3)
- Firefox 3.0.8 (SAFE mode!!) on WinXP (SP2) (machine#1)
- IETab on FF 3.0.8 on Win XP (SP2)(machine#1)
- IE 6.0 on WinXP (SP2)(machine#1)
Attached are two screen grabs:
#1 is of the screen shown in ALL the above after clicking on the Print Invoice PDF icon on the mobile bills page.
#2 is what happens when the "Goto" (target) icon is clicked. Please note that EVERY time this page is entered or refreshed the window size is shrunk to EXACTLY as shown - this is patently wrong at any level. This behaviour has existed since my first report of this problem over three months ago.
PLEASE can someone resolve this issue ASAP? It has wasted more than enough of my time time now (I reckon at least 20 hours in total if not more - another five of those (on and off) today - I started trying to get this working at 14:00 today - it's now 22:05! It's still not working!)
Best regards,Bob Lewis.
28-04-2009 10:25 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
It returns to haunt!!
The problem is I think it has (partially) caught my account now. I try to view my PDF copy and I get the grey screen you show in your screenshot and it hangs for a bit, and then a single page appears in the Adobe software in a separate screen.
I have to close that, but even then I am unable to view my bill in full on the normal screen (again like your screenshot). I am however, able to download the PDF bill in full.
Something must have changed in the last few days (literally the last few because I was able to download my bill fine a couple of days ago).
This is the first problem I have had with my account RE PDF copies.
Tom
28-04-2009 10:38 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
Hi Bob
It returns to haunt!!
The problem is I think it has (partially) caught my account now. I try to view my PDF copy and I get the grey screen you show in your screenshot and it hangs for a bit, and then a single page appears in the Adobe software in a separate screen.
I have to close that, but even then I am unable to view my bill in full on the normal screen (again like your screenshot). I am however, able to download the PDF bill in full.
Something must have changed in the last few days (literally the last few because I was able to download my bill fine a couple of days ago).
This is the first problem I have had with my account RE PDF copies.![]()
Tom
Hi Tom,
Yes HAUNT is right.
I was going to do a video grab of what happened but realised it would be painful to obfuscate all the private information so I used still image grabs. I DO get the popup (in my case it asks me if I want to view or download) either way I can do both of those things i.e. I can view it or download it BUT it is the default pdf of the SINGLE first page only. No option available as previously to grab the whole invoice. If I cancel (or save) that first PDF download it matters not. There is no option to do anything except download a single selected page (any of the 1 through 6) which is not what any of us want. It is SO frustrating.
Best regards, Bob.
28-04-2009 11:11 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
... I am however, able to download the PDF bill in full. ....
Tom
Sorry Tom,
I misread that part previously. Are you saying that although you can't view your full bill you can still download the full bill?
What do you do to achieve that? Are you getting that extra box that I used to see but now don't, where it asks how many (or which) pages you want?
Just to clarify attached is another screen grab of a larger portion of the "GoTo" screen so you can see all the data entry boxes that are there.
Best regards, Bob
29-04-2009 03:05 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
Yes you read it correctly. I cannot view my bill online anymore, but I am able to download it through the DocumentDirect software in full.
- Once I get the "grey" area, I click on the "Download pages" button (seventh button along on the toolbar).
- I then get a dialog box asking me whether I want to download: the original document, full document, a range from page x to page x, or current page. I also get the option to download as ZIP (see the screenshot attached).
- I then get a message telling me it is preparing the file from the server, which is then followed by a "Download" button.
- Click on the "Download" button and it works fine.
Does this help?
I tried it on my Windows Vista laptop yesterday and got the problem, but have also tried it on my Ubuntu Linux laptop and can replicate exactly the same error.
Any probs or questions, please shout.
Best Regards
Tom
29-04-2009 08:52 PM
Online Billing Not Working
- Mark as New
- Bookmark
- Subscribe
- Highlight
- Email to a Friend
- Report inappropriate content
Well guess what? It's now different again today. I'm getting the page now Tom, that you show in your screen shot - I wasn't yesterday (no idea why the change) although I was getting the other screen (after clicking on the Goto Page icon).
After some more fudging about I FINALLY managed to download ALL my outstanding invoices from November last year via IE6. Still no joy trying to get it done with Firefox. I have the FF 3.5 beta 4 now too so maybe I'll try that once it's an RC - a bit to go for that yet I think.
I also made a video screen grab of FF (now up to 3.0.10 as of this a.m.) showing all OK up until clicking the download button, but it's a 3.5 Mb .swf file so I'll have to load it up onto one of my web servers for anyone who wants to see it. I'll put a link back here if I get the time to upload it in the next day or so.
Out of interest I also noticed today that the Vodafone main page and the mobile bills page are both SEVERELY broken in Firefox but "appear" OK under IE6 - the pages do NOT render correctly - yet more proof that precious little adherence to web coding standards is going on - and that's without even looking at the 363 coding errors & 320 warnings on the home page as reported by the W3C Validation page !
Someone, somewhere is NOT doing the job they should be in testing against the leading browsers, never mind coding to standards.
I give up. I just hope that I can fudge the downloads OK again the same time next quarter, since I can't see this issue being resolved any time soon seeing as how it's already been dragging on for over four months now.
Best regards, Bob L.






