main_icn_My_Vodafone main_icn_Search main_icn_Chevron_right main_icn_Chevron_down main_icn_Close main_icn_Menu social-facebook social-google-plus social-linkedin social-twitter social-youtube main_icn_Community_or_Foundation main_icn_Location main_icn_Network_signal
Menu Toggle
Keeping the UK connected is our main priority. Find out how we're doing thishere.
Close announcement

Off topic

Benefits of the hydrogen fuel cell trains

1: Seeker

I want to discuss the environmental benefits of the hydrogen fuel cell trains here.
Hydrogen vehicles have in 100% zero emissions and no carbon dioxide emission. Hydrogen technology will advance in the future to such a point that fuel cells become a viable alternative.
Share your opinion on how hydrogen will be the future here with me.
Thank you.

View more options
17: Community Champion

Hydrogen fuel cells have been The Next Big Thing for so long that you'd assume they'd have happened by now if they were going to to.   Part of the issue is the transport and storage of a highly flammable gas, not to mention restrictions on road use in tunnels in some countries (they don't even allow LPG).   A lot of that (although not the question mark over tunnels) goes away with rail because you have a more tightly-controlled infrastructure, especially as regards re-fuelling - it may even be that the gas can be produced on-site.   All that makes it an attractive proposition for railways and, of course, it obviates the issues connected with electricity (a lot of infrastructure, damage to overhead wires) and the pollution issue of diesel.  Potentially, there's much to like.

Interestingly, I remember hearing a fire expert talking about hydrogen quite a while ago.   They pointed out that a pressurised gas escapes vertically and disperses and said that hydrogen burns with a blue flame and is therefore visible.   By contrast, petrol leaks and spreads and burns with an invisible flame.   There's a risk of explosion in both cases, but it's different, and hydrogen isn't necessarily more dangerous.

Obviously, hydrogen leaking from a stalled train in a tunnel would be scary, but trains are less likely to suffer tank damage than cars due to the confining nature of the rails.

View more options