Ask
Reply
Solution
18-03-2022 11:27 AM - edited 18-03-2022 10:05 PM
On the 100 Fibre (FTTP) package my Router on Ethernet and my WiFi Speed for Download and Upload were all in the about 109Mbps range
After upgrading to the Pro 500 package at the Router and on Ethernet the speed is correct at over 500 Mbps
But on WiFi the Download Speed is about 190Mbps while the Upload Speed is about 260Mbps regardless of how close the computer is to the Router. That 30% difference was never apparent on the 100 Plan
I am not able to find any reason that Download is slower than Upload and I do not know if that is common or correct.
Any ideas on improving the balance between Upload and Download the would be appreciated
Solved! Go to best answer.
07-04-2022 02:29 PM - edited 07-04-2022 03:04 PM
The OP probably needs to spend a couple of weeks repeatedly testing at a couple of different times of the day, and logging it, to get a full picture. (Busy time/quiet time) They need to use the same device at the same spot. There is likely more than one factor here. 1) Contention is likely to be one of those factors at peak times, 2) WiFi tests are notoriously fickle, even if you are testing in exactly the same spot when you do it. ( I just now did six consecutive tests, sitting in the same spot, on my Samsung S10+. The upstream ranged between 480Mb and 670Mb whilst the downstream ranged between 320MB and 715Mb. 3) Some of the OP's perception could be to do with scale. Any difference between upstream and downstream is likely to be greater on a 500MB connection than a 100Mb connection.
EDIT: I just did some speed tests on a high-powered ASUS Netbook. The upstream was consistently slower than downstream. The mean difference over six tests was 88.2Mb. This was with the netbook only two metres away from the VF router. The test server was the same throughout.
07-04-2022 11:50 AM - edited 07-04-2022 11:59 AM
I find the same on the 900 product and when connected by ethernet, but this is no surprise. It is likely that some of your problem is due to contention in your area, although in your case, maybe to do with WiFi issues also. People who share the fibre capacity from your nearest exchange or node will be using more downstream bandwidth than upstream. At busy times I sometimes get less than the 900Mb I pay for, but the upstream is invariably >940Mb. Most people, unless they are running a media server or are uploading large files, mostly use downstream. To use the downstream, some upstream is used to maintain a 'conversation' between your devices and the servers, but this is minimal even if you are caning your connection. The most likely time of the day to get the upstream and downstream almost the same would be around 5.00 am in a residential area. If you test at that time, you will get a better idea of how much of your problem is to do with your set up. I did this test at 5.30 am.
08-04-2022 11:53 AM
Thank you for the reply
On LAN my speeds are plus minus 540Mbps upload and download - I have not found any great variation based on time of day or day of week. WiFi Download sits around 190 to 230 while upload is more consistent at around 260 - 270
Out of interest with 900Mbps through LAN what speed do you have on WiFi on the 5Ghz channel? Somewhere I read that WiFi speed is about 50% of LAN Speed - no idea if that is true or false
Regards
09-04-2022 08:25 AM - edited 09-04-2022 08:32 AM
The best measure of your connection bandwidth is what you get get directly connected to your router via CAT5e or CAT6 Ethernet cable to a capable Tower PC or Laptop. If you are getting the speeds you pay for 90% of the time, you are right not to let yourself get distracted by the fickleness and vagaries of WiFi. On your 500Mb, if you are getting sufficient WiFi speeds to comfortably manage, e.g. 4K streaming anywhere in your property, then all is well.
To answer your specific question about the 900Mb product I just now did three tests in quick succession checking first that my ASUS netbook was connected through a 5GHz channel. Up and downstream consistently gave me well over 500Mb two metres from the main router. The image shows my best result. So, in this case WiFi was a little less than 60% of what I would get over Ethernet LAN. On my Samsung phone I sometimes get > 700Mb.
Incidentally, you can test your internal LAN speed between your main PC and your main router using free software. https://totusoft.com/lanspeed You will find that your read speed (download) is always faster than your write speed (upload)
In the farthest corner of the house I got 68Mb down and 75Mb up. This assures me that I can stream 4K anywhere even connected by WiFi. As it happens, I have ethernet all over the house, but that is a different story. 😁 (25Mbminimum available bandwidth is sufficient for 4K)
09-04-2022 01:20 PM
09-04-2022 01:28 PM