Ask
Reply
Solution
06-02-2014 09:58 AM
15-02-2014 10:43 PM
15-02-2014 10:58 PM
24-03-2014 06:43 PM
06-02-2014 10:57 AM
26-08-2014 02:51 PM
26-08-2014 03:45 PM
@dsw76 I’m pleased you also found it interesting J I think that if the competitors start building features such as these into their services as standard, then it’ll hopefully keep everyone else (Vodafone, I’m looking at you!) on their toes to roll it, or something equivalent out.
However, if you’re considering a move from Voda to EE, make sure you have plenty of opportunity to test first. I’ve first-hand experience of a recent corporate shift from Voda to EE, and whilst it’s fair to say that you currently see 3G rather than 2G in more places on EE than we did on Voda, EE’s reliability in comparison to Voda has been abmismal – no point having a signal show if your calls go straight through to answer-phone or you hear three pips when trying to make a call L
@humadoon I’ve gone full-circle with my personal phone… 3 years with Voda, then 3 yrs with O2, and now I’m into my second year with Voda again. Visiting many different places, I’d say that traditionally the blackspots have been 50/50 between the two operators, i.e. I found as many Voda blackspots as I did O2 blackspots. I’d say that O2 had better urban indoor 3G coverage than Voda due to them rolling out UMTS 900MHz a few years before Voda (VF are catching up on this alongside their 4G rollout), but Voda are more reliable and better call quality.
The cities where Voda have completed their 2G/3G upgrades alongside the 4G rollout generally have superb coverage now, where I’m frequently enjoying indoor 3G/4G coverage where EE customers are barely getting 2G and poor old Three customers get nothing.
I guess it’s still that age-old situation of trying to find the network which overall works best for you personally.
26-08-2014 04:30 PM
27-08-2014 08:27 AM
@humadoon: Interesting... Being as O2 and Vodafone supposedly began site-sharing for their transmitters (i.e. a Vodafone transmitter on every O2 site, and vice-versa) one would presume that each operator's coverage in the 4G-upgraded areas would be pretty much identical, with perhaps just a little variation depending on whose transmitter is furthest up the mast/pole.
I've found a similar situation in a couple of spots in Nottingham where I know O2 had indoor 3G coverage when I was with them previously, yet Vodafone - despite the upgrades - still fall back to 2G only, which in itself is a mystery when the 4G signal is 800MHz and the 2G is 900MHz, meaning 4G should have slightly better penetration.
Either it's not as cut-and-dried as it seems on the face of it, or Vodafone still haven't fully completed the site-sharing project, even in areas such as London and Nottingham which went live with 4G almost a year ago now. It's such a shame that all of the networks are so secretive about specific areas/sites, meaning we'll probably never get a real answer about what is going on in spots like this.